ifacethoughts

Benefits Of Online Repositories

I ended up on a Windows machine for a couple of days, my Linux machine was inaccessible. I was using a Windows machine after a gap of about an year or so. My usage was limited to only testing on Windows specific applications.

I had to install a couple of applications to get my basic development environment up. And was that painful! I have got so used to the online repository way of installing applications that the Windows way of installing applications sucked most of the energy out of me.

Most of the Linux distributions have online repositories of software packages available. It is usually just one command or couple of clicks in the GUI to look for and install a specific package. It deals with dependencies, or at the least warns you about them gracefully. For example, on my Arch Linux machine I have to use the command sudo pacman -S vim. These commands not only install packages, they can also seamlessly upgrade them or update your cache of the repositories. Also, unlike a lot of installations they also handle the uninstallation and downgrading for you. In fact, on Arch Linux, even my OS is upgraded seamlessly.

I will not say that the Windows way takes a lot longer, but it surely is tedious. So much so that sometimes it discourages me from trying out an application. Also, I find the whole Add/Remove programs unusable, especially because, you end up getting multiple entries for a single installation you did. Then there are also the Windows updates, but they have been involved more in creating problems than solving them.

Of course, there is an effort in maintaining the online repositories, and there have been problems in managing dependencies sometimes. But majority of the times it just works, and the problems have been handled by the community. There is also some work being done to improve compatibility across distributions. However, even today, the packages are created and maintained by the community. To some extent the community itself has retained the diversity, which perhaps shows that it is in response to what the user wants.

So what does Microsoft have to do to get something like this up and running? Windows has some good third-party applications, but they are hardly visible or accessible. These developers and the users both need this. But I do not think Microsoft will be able to do it. Not because it cannot do the design or the technology, but because it has not shown any inclination towards harnessing a community. And without community it will not work.

It is typically said that Linux asks its user to know a lot more about the system to properly use it. In this case though, I believe, the Linux installation is more intuitive and usable.

Discussion [Participate or Link]

  1. Kevin said:

    I’m an old school Slackware user, so I prefer source over binary on Linux. That said, I’ve never had any real issues with the Windows way of handling things. With a few minor exceptions it has always just worked… Generally when it hasn’t the issue can be traced back to developers who roll their own installer, or use a sub-par installer package.

    Kevin

  2. Rohit said:

    I have switched over to Ubuntu Linux about 6-8 months ago and I am absolutely satisfied. And I agree with you that repositories is a fantastic way getting and upgrading software. It’s so simple but it does depend on availability of a decent internet connection.

  3. Binny V A said:

    Yes, Linux has that advantage. But Windows makes up for it by having a lot more software and easier single app install systems.

  4. Daniel said:

    Which software did you require? Have you taken a look at BitNami?

  5. Is it too easy to install open source packages? | OpenLogic Blogs said:

    […] Abhijit Nadgouda says in "Benefits of Online Repositories", it only takes a simple command or two in Linux to download and install or upgrade a […]

  6. En IT-students første erfaring med Linux « Lapskaus fra et liv i dein binære kverdag said:

    […] så kjæm æ tell det som heite Online Repositories. Æ veit ka det e, mæn kor mange skal æ krysse av før? Det jo en umasse med plassa og navn, og […]

Say your thought!

If you want to use HTML you can use these tags: <a>, <em>, <strong>, <abbr>, <code>, <blockquote>. Closing the tags will be appreciated as this site uses valid XHTML.

freshthoughts

contactme

Abhijit Nadgouda
iface Consulting
India
+91 9819820312
My bookmarks

badgesand...

This is the weblog of Abhijit Nadgouda where he writes down his thoughts on software development and related topics. You are invited to subscribe to the feed to stay updated or check out more subscription options. Or you can choose to browse by one of the topics.